Adultery has long been a central issue in the realm of divorce law, and in Scotland, it plays a key role in determining the grounds for the dissolution of a marriage. Scots law, distinct from other parts of the UK, provides a clear framework for handling divorce, including the grounds for divorce based on adultery. However, understanding how adultery fits within the broader legal system can help individuals navigate the emotional and legal complexities of such a situation.
The Grounds for Divorce in Scotland
In Scotland, a divorce can be sought on one of four primary grounds: separation for a period of one year (with consent) or two years (without consent), unreasonable behaviour, or adultery. Of these, adultery is one of the least commonly cited reasons for a divorce action.
What Constitutes Adultery?
Adultery, in the legal context, is defined as voluntary sexual intercourse between a married person and someone who is not their spouse. It is important to note that the definition of adultery in Scots law requires sexual intercourse; other forms of infidelity, such as emotional or online affairs, do not meet the legal threshold for adultery. For adultery to be considered a ground for divorce, the offending spouse must have committed the act of sexual intercourse with someone outside the marriage.
In order to use adultery as the basis for a divorce action, the accusing spouse must provide evidence of the adultery. This can be in the form of the offending spouse’s admission, or, in some cases, through circumstantial evidence such as photographs, text messages, or witness testimony. Sometimes it is proved by a private detective’s report. However, proving adultery can sometimes be challenging, especially in cases where one spouse denies the accusations or when there is insufficient evidence to support the claim.
Legal Implications of Adultery
In Scotland, once adultery is proven or admitted, the aggrieved spouse can apply for a divorce immediately, without the need to wait for separation periods. However, this does not automatically grant them favourable financial outcomes or childcare arrangements for children. Adultery is primarily a ground for proving the breakdown of the marriage, and any decisions regarding finances or children will be addressed separately.
It is important to remember that adultery can have significant emotional and psychological consequences on both spouses and their children. The legal process, while providing a framework for dissolution, is not designed to address the emotional impact of infidelity. Many individuals opt for counselling or mediation to help manage the emotional fallout from adultery during divorce proceedings.
The Role of Consent in Adultery-Based Divorce
One of the critical aspects of adultery-based divorce is that the non-offending spouse must not have condoned or forgiven the adultery. If the aggrieved spouse continues to live with the adulterer for more than three months after learning about the adultery, it is considered that they have implicitly accepted the situation, and this may prevent them from using adultery as a ground for divorce. In other words, the law requires that the marriage be irreparably broken down, and this time frame helps ensure that the spouse seeking divorce has not reconciled or accepted the wrongdoing.
Adultery, Divorce, and Financial Settlements
While adultery is a valid ground for divorce in Scotland, it does not normally have a bearing on financial settlements. The law operates on the principle of fairness in dividing matrimonial property. Even if one party is responsible for adultery, financial settlements are determined by factors like the length of the marriage, the assets and liabilities of each party at the time of separation, and the resources of the parties.
In conclusion, adultery remains a factor in divorce proceedings in Scotland. While it can immediately lead to the dissolution of a marriage, it does not directly affect financial settlements or other divorce-related outcomes. As with all matters of divorce, it is essential for individuals to seek professional legal advice to ensure their rights and interests are protected throughout the process.
If you would like to discuss this further, please get in touch with our Family Law Experts.
You may be interested in reading: 10 Common Divorce Myths in Scotland
DISCLAIMER
The content of this page is for information only. It is not intended to be construed as legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice. Gibson Kerr Ltd accepts no responsibility for the content of any third party website to which this webpage refers. Gibson Kerr Ltd is regulated by the Law Society of Scotland.